Should You Work With an Agent Who Has Sold in the Building?
Prior building transactions can be useful, but current verification, representation and conflicts matter just as much.
Prior building transactions can be useful, but current verification, representation and conflicts matter just as much.
Experience is a starting point, not a guarantee
An agent who has completed a purchase in the building may know how management communicates, which application steps took time and which documents buyers commonly need. Ask when that experience occurred, whether the agent represented the buyer or seller, and what has changed since.
A past closing does not establish today’s financing policy, reserve requirement, charges, assessments, subletting rules or willingness to approve a purchaser. Obtain current written information for the apartment and transaction you are considering.
Questions that test the advantage
Ask which unit and transaction type the agent handled, allowing for client confidentiality. Ask what obstacles arose, who resolved them and what documents supported the decision. The agent should be able to discuss the process without revealing another buyer’s private finances.
Ask whether the agent or their brokerage currently represents the seller or other parties. Clarify who represents you and what any proposed dual-agency arrangement would mean before consenting. Building familiarity does not erase a conflict.
A useful example—and its limits
Suppose management has a specific submission sequence and an attorney-review prerequisite. An experienced agent might flag the sequence early, reducing avoidable rework. That is a hypothetical coordination benefit; it does not mean the board will approve an application or close on your preferred date.
Conversely, an agent new to the building can still be effective if they obtain the current requirements, involve the right professionals and maintain a clear issues log. Compare the quality of the work plan rather than counting transactions alone.
Compare candidates consistently
Score each candidate on relevant property experience, evidence quality, responsiveness, representation and service terms. Ask who covers absences and how unresolved questions are escalated. A building specialist should still compare alternatives outside the building if those better fit your needs.
Use our agent interview checklist before committing. No agent can guarantee a board decision, legal result, mortgage approval or investment return.
Sources and review
Editorial review: October 25, 2026. Check current requirements with the relevant professional and source before acting.
Put your next question to work
Compare buyer’s agents or register interest in an agent introduction. NYC Buyers Guide is an independent educational website, not a real estate brokerage. Agent introductions are not yet available; an introduction or response timeframe is not guaranteed.